Our recommendations: Mascara for sensitive eyes

If you’ve got sensitive eyes, wearing mascara can sometimes be complicated. That’s true even though you’re supposed to be able to wear it and have long lashes for days on end. However, when your eyes are watery and stinging, you might just feel like giving up on mascara entirely.

With that said, the best mascara for sensitive eyes is a hypoallergenic one. These are gentle mascaras, which can give you the long, thick lashes you want without any itching, redness, or stinging.

Immediately below, we’ll go over these five hypoallergenic mascaras you may wish to try.

Choosing the best mascara for sensitive eyes

Before we get to the various mascaras from which you have to choose, you need to know how to choose the best hypoallergenic mascara for sensitive eyes. The things to keep in the forefront of your mind are:

  • Keep things simple.
  • Go for a traditional lengthening or volumizing mascara.
  • Don’t use fiber mascaras even though they’re popular.

On this last point, they add extra length to your lashes, sure … but the fiber they use to do so can fall into your eyes. Talk about added irritation!

Read the label

Make sure to check the label to see if “hypoallergenic” is written there. If it’s not, then you know the manufacturer has likely included ingredients that might be allergens.

Another phrase that can give you a good indication as to whether the mascara might be safe for your sensitive eyes is “ophthalmologist tested.” If it says that, it means the manufacturer consulted an eye doctor when they tested the mascara’s formula.

Also, take into account that even when the label says “natural ingredients” or something similar, that doesn’t mean it’s hypoallergenic. There are plenty of natural ingredients that a person can be allergic to or that your skin might be sensitive to.

Get new mascara

This might sound a bit like a “duh” statement considering the fact that this entire article is about helping you choose some new mascaras for sensitive eyes. However, many people don’t think about how long they might have had a tube of mascara sitting around.

Remember that bacteria can grow inside your mascara tube. Bacterial growth can cause eye infections. It’s therefore recommended that you get rid of any mascaras you’ve had longer than three months.

Now, with the above in mind, let’s take a look at some of our mascara recommendations for sensitive eyes!

Almay One Coat Thickening Mascara

Fragrance-free and hypoallergenic, this thickening mascara is filled with vitamin B5 and aloe vera. It’s great because it resists both flaking and smudging. Dermatologists and ophthalmologists tested its formula to make sure that it’s easy to apply even if you wear contact lenses or have severe sensitivity issues.

Clinique High Impact Mascara

Many people feel that Clinique is amazing due to how gentle their products are. Their high-impact mascara is no exception! This mascara has no phthalates, fragrances, or parabens. Clinique says the product has been tested safe for those with sensitive eyes. Moreover, this mascara doesn’t smudge or run and builds great volume!

Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara + Primer

This mascara is known for its incredible multitasking ability. First, whisk on the primer, and then brush on the mascara and watch as your lashes take on a fuller, longer look. Moreover, you’ll find that this mascara works perfectly for those with sensitive eyes since its formula is free of synthetic fragrances, silicones, sulfates, and parabens. In short, it’s purposely designed with hypoallergenic ingredients in mind.

Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes 4-in-1 Mascara

Vegan mascara. Who would have thought? Not only are there no animal products within this mascara’s ingredients, but it also lacks things like phthalates and parabens. Even better, however, is the fact that this hypoallergenic mascara boasts ingredients like provitamin B5, vitamin C, olive esters, and rice bran wax. Of course, together, these ingredients lengthen, condition, and provide your lashes with protection against free radicals!

ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara

The last hypoallergenic mascara on our list, this one contains shea butter, keratin, and beeswax. It has a cruelty-free formula, which neither flakes nor budges once applied. Completely free of common irritants, it nourishes your lashes while lengthening, strengthening, and conditioning them!

Editors' Recommendations